Best Mocktail Recipes

Homemade Sodas

Roy Rogers Mocktail Recipe With a Simmered Pomegranate Grenadine

8 Mins read
Roy Rogers mocktail recipe: two glasses of cola over ice with red grenadine and a cherry, a jar of grenadine between

This Roy Rogers mocktail recipe pours 1 cup of cold cola over ice and about 2 tablespoons of grenadine simmered from 100% pomegranate juice, then finishes each glass with a maraschino cherry. Each glass comes to about 159 calories, or about 61 with zero-sugar cola. Measures are in the recipe card.

Start with the grenadine and the rest is easy. A Roy Rogers drink is only three things in a glass: cola, grenadine and a cherry. When the grenadine is real pomegranate, deep ruby and a little tart, that small red layer at the bottom changes the whole glass. The cola tastes brighter, a touch fruity, never syrupy.

It takes five minutes at the stove and one small saucepan. I love that the grenadine is the only thing you really make, and that you decide how sweet it is.

A Lighter Roy Rogers Mocktail Recipe: The Numbers Per Glass

Most of the sugar in a Roy Rogers is in the cola, not in the grenadine. One cup of regular cola holds about 25.4 g of carbohydrate and 103 calories by USDA values, while our grenadine adds about 6.3 g of sugar per glass on top of the juice. So the lightest swap is in the soda.

One glass of Roy RogersCaloriesCarbohydrates
Regular cola + pomegranate grenadine (this recipe)about 159about 40 g
Half cola, half sparkling waterabout 108about 27 g
Homemade cola syrup (below) + sparkling waterabout 108about 28 g
Zero-sugar colaabout 61about 15 g

Replacing half of the cola with plain sparkling water keeps the color, the fizz and the cherry, and cuts about a third of the calories. Zero-sugar cola goes further. Either way, the grenadine made from real juice helps with keeping added sugar down, because you add only the sugar you choose to the syrup.

Roy Rogers vs Shirley Temple, and Where the Name Comes From

The Roy Rogers goes back to the 1940s and carries the name of Roy Rogers, the American cowboy actor and singer. It became the cola-based sister of the Shirley Temple, a drink everyone at the table could order, and for decades both were the go-to alcohol-free order at diners and bars across the country.

The difference is in the soda:

Roy RogersShirley Temple
SodaColaGinger ale or lemon-lime soda
Color in the glassDark, with a red glow at the bottomPink to red-gold
GrenadineYesYes
GarnishMaraschino cherryMaraschino cherry

If you prefer the lighter, gingery one, our Shirley Temple mocktail recipe shakes its grenadine cold in a jar in one minute. Here, the grenadine is simmered, which makes it a little thicker so it holds its red layer under the dark cola.

Grenadine Is Pomegranate, Not Cherry

Grenadine takes its name from the French word for pomegranate, and it was first a pomegranate syrup. Turn a bottle around and the label often lists a sweetener first, then flavoring and a color additive, with little or no pomegranate. That candy-red taste is why so many people think grenadine is cherry.

A homemade pomegranate grenadine tastes of fruit: tart, deep, a bit like cranberry. Its color comes only from the juice.

Simmering 1/3 cup of 100% pomegranate juice with a tablespoon of sugar for about 5 minutes reduces it to roughly 1/4 cup, just enough for 2 glasses. Thicker than the juice, it sinks and stays at the bottom until you stir.

Use a pomegranate juice that says 100% juice with no sugar added. The lime at the end is not for sourness; it wakes up the fruit. Any grenadine left in the jar makes the red base of a layered sunrise mocktail the next morning.

Pomegranate juice, sugar, a lime, maraschino cherries, cola and ice laid out on a pale stone counter

The Right Ratio of Grenadine to Cola

About 2 tablespoons of grenadine for 1 cup of cola is my favorite balance: a clear pomegranate note, a deep red glow, and cola that still tastes like cola. Bar versions range from a splash to an ounce or more of bottled grenadine.

Taste after the first glass. Less grenadine gives a cleaner, drier cola; more gives a sweeter, rosier drink. Because the homemade syrup is less sweet than most bottles, you can be a little more generous with it.

Roy Rogers Mocktail Recipe, Step by Step

The card has the exact measures. Here is the how and why behind each move.

Step 1: Simmer the grenadine

Warm the pomegranate juice and sugar in a small saucepan, stirring until the sugar disappears. Let it bubble gently, not hard, for about 5 minutes.

It is ready when it has lost about a quarter of its volume and coats a spoon lightly. Off the heat, stir in the lime juice. Let it cool completely: warm syrup would melt the ice and flatten the cola.

Step 2: Ice, then grenadine

Fill the glasses with ice right to the rim. A full glass melts slower and keeps the drink cold and fizzy longer. Spoon the grenadine over the ice; it slides down and pools at the bottom.

Step 3: Cola, one stir, a cherry

Pour the cola slowly down the side of the glass, so the bubbles do not foam over. Use cola straight from the fridge and from a freshly opened bottle or can; flat cola makes a flat Roy Rogers.

Give one gentle stir from the bottom, just enough to lift some red into the cola, and finish with a maraschino cherry on top. Savor it while the fizz is lively.

Homemade Cola Syrup for a From-Scratch Roy Rogers

For a Roy Rogers made entirely at home, make a small batch of cola syrup and mix it with sparkling water. It tastes of citrus and warm spice rather than of the bottled kind, and it is lovely.

In a small saucepan, combine 1 cup of water, 1/2 cup of packed brown sugar, the zest of 1 orange and 1 lime in wide strips, 1 cinnamon stick and a pinch of ground nutmeg. Simmer gently for 10 minutes, take it off the heat, add 1/2 teaspoon of vanilla extract and the juice of the lime, and let it steep until cool. Strain into a jar and keep it in the fridge.

The batch makes about 1 cup, enough for 8 glasses. For one Roy Rogers, stir 2 tablespoons of cola syrup into 3/4 cup of cold sparkling water over ice, then add the grenadine and the cherry. Each glass then carries about 1 tablespoon of brown sugar from the syrup, roughly 13.5 g of carbohydrate, about half of what a cup of regular cola holds. The homemade cola has no caffeine.

Roy Rogers Variations

  • Roy Rogers float. Skip half the ice and add a small scoop of vanilla ice cream on top. Pour the cola very slowly; it foams.
  • Extra cherry. Add a teaspoon of the syrup from the cherry jar with the grenadine for a deeper red and a stronger cherry note. If cherry cola is your thing, our dirty cherry Coke adds cherry syrup and a creamy finish.
  • Other sodas. The same grenadine and cherry work on Dr Pepper or on root beer, which is alcohol-free despite its name. For the cream-topped style on a Dr Pepper base, see our dirty Dr Pepper recipe.
  • Fresh garnish. No maraschino cherries? A fresh cherry or a raspberry on a pick looks just as pretty.

Serving a Roy Rogers to a Crowd

A Roy Rogers is a party drink, often the one poured for the kids so they get a fancy glass too. Make the grenadine a day ahead and keep it in a closed jar in the fridge; put it back in the fridge after serving, within 2 hours at most (FoodSafety.gov).

Do not mix a pitcher in advance: the cola goes flat. Set out the glasses with the grenadine already spooned in, a bucket of ice, cold cola and a bowl of cherries, and pour each glass to order. For more classics to serve alongside, browse our homemade sodas.

What Studies Say About Sweet Drinks and Pomegranate Juice

No study has looked at the Roy Rogers itself. The research is on its two main ingredients: sugar-sweetened soda and pomegranate juice.

On the soda side, a 2025 dose-response meta-analysis (PMID 40122386) pooled 29 cohort studies. Each extra daily serving of sugar-sweetened drinks was linked to a higher risk of type 2 diabetes, with moderate certainty, while total sugar from food was not consistently linked to it. These are observational studies: they show a link, not a cause.

They still point to the same easy habit: keep sweet sodas as a treat, and the lighter glasses above help with that.

On the pomegranate side, a 2023 meta-analysis (PMID 37461211) of 14 trials with 573 people found that drinking pomegranate juice lowered systolic blood pressure by about 5 mmHg on average, and that the effect faded after two months. Those trials used whole glasses of juice, some more than 300 ml a day. The couple of tablespoons in a grenadine are far from that, so this is a reason to enjoy real fruit in the glass, not a health effect to expect.

Safety: Caffeine, Sugar and Kids

  • Caffeine. A cup of regular cola has about 22 mg of caffeine by USDA values, and zero-sugar cola about 28 mg. The FDA lists caffeinated soft drinks at 23 to 83 mg per 12-ounce serving, says drinks with caffeine should be avoided for children younger than 2, and suggests talking with a health care professional about a child’s or teen’s caffeine intake; for most adults, up to 400 mg a day is not generally associated with negative effects (FDA). Caffeine-free cola or the homemade cola syrup solves it for kids.
  • Added sugar. The Dietary Guidelines for Americans recommend no added sugar for children younger than 11, and no more than 10 grams of added sugars per meal for teens and adults; sugar-sweetened beverages are one of the leading sources of added sugars in the US diet (CDC). For children, keep a Roy Rogers for special occasions and pour the half-sparkling version.
  • Zero-sugar cola and PKU. Many zero-sugar colas are sweetened with aspartame. The FDA considers it safe for the general population, but people with phenylketonuria should avoid or restrict it; the label carries a phenylalanine statement (FDA).

Where the Numbers Come From

Cold cola, a ruby spoonful of pomegranate, one cherry. That is the whole Roy Rogers mocktail recipe, and the sweetness is yours to choose.

Roy Rogers mocktail recipe: two glasses of cola over ice with red grenadine and a cherry, a jar of grenadine between
Print Pin
No ratings yet

Roy Rogers Mocktail

Cold cola over ice, a ruby layer of grenadine simmered from real pomegranate juice, and a cherry on top. The cowboy cousin of the Shirley Temple, with the sugar in your hands.
Course Drinks
Cuisine American
Keyword cola and grenadine, homemade grenadine, kids mocktail, roy rogers, roy rogers drink, roy rogers mocktail, roy rogers mocktail recipe
Prep Time 5 minutes
Cook Time 5 minutes
Total Time 10 minutes
Servings 2 glasses
Calories 159kcal
Author Valérie C

Ingredients

Pomegranate grenadine

  • 1/3 cup pomegranate juice 80 ml, 100% juice with no sugar added
  • 3 tsp granulated sugar 1 tablespoon; use a little less for a tarter syrup
  • 1/2 tbsp lime juice freshly squeezed

Roy Rogers

  • 2 cup cola 480 ml, well chilled, from a freshly opened bottle or can
  • 2 cherry maraschino cherries with stems, 1 per glass
  • 2 cup ice enough to fill 2 glasses

Instructions

  • Put the pomegranate juice and sugar in a small saucepan and bring to a gentle simmer, stirring until the sugar dissolves. Let it bubble softly for about 5 minutes, until it has reduced to about 1/4 cup and coats a spoon lightly. Take it off the heat, stir in the lime juice and cool it, 10 minutes in a bowl of ice water or longer in the fridge.
    Small saucepan of ruby red pomegranate juice simmering into grenadine, a wooden spoon in it
  • Fill 2 glasses with ice right to the rim. Spoon about 2 tablespoons of the cooled grenadine into each glass; it settles at the bottom in a red layer.
    Glass with ice and a layer of red pomegranate grenadine at the bottom, a small jar of grenadine beside it
  • Pour 1 cup of cold cola slowly down the side of each glass so it keeps its fizz. Give one gentle stir from the bottom with a long spoon, then finish with a maraschino cherry on top of the ice. Serve right away.
    Glass of cola over ice with a red tint at the bottom, a maraschino cherry on top and a bar spoon

Notes

Nutrition is per glass, from USDA values for regular cola, pomegranate juice, sugar, lime juice and a maraschino cherry.
With zero-sugar cola, each glass is about 61 calories; with half cola and half sparkling water, about 108.
The grenadine keeps a few days in a closed jar in the fridge. Shake it before pouring.

Nutrition

Calories: 159kcal

Frequently Asked Questions

Is there an alcoholic Roy Rogers drink?

The Roy Rogers was created as a drink without alcohol, and that is the whole idea behind it: a festive glass anyone at the table can order. This recipe keeps it that way, with cola, grenadine and a cherry.

What’s a good non-alcoholic drink at a bar?

A Roy Rogers is one of the easiest, because every bar has cola and grenadine. A Shirley Temple, made with ginger ale or lemon-lime soda instead of cola, is the other classic, and soda water with fresh lime is the least sweet choice.

What is a Dr Pepper with grenadine called?

It has no official name of its own. It is the Roy Rogers formula on a Dr Pepper base, and it works well, since the cherry notes of the soda meet the tart pomegranate of the grenadine.

Is grenadine cherry or pomegranate?

Grenadine is a pomegranate syrup; its name comes from the French word for pomegranate. Many bottled versions list a sweetener, flavoring and a color additive ahead of any fruit, which is why it often tastes like cherry candy.

Does a Roy Rogers have caffeine?

Yes, if you use regular cola: about 22 mg in a cup by USDA values. Caffeine-free cola makes a Roy Rogers without caffeine, which is the better pick for children.

What is the difference between a Roy Rogers and a Shirley Temple?

The soda. A Roy Rogers uses cola, so it is dark, with a red glow at the bottom; a Shirley Temple uses ginger ale or lemon-lime soda, so it turns pink. Both take grenadine and a maraschino cherry.

Photo of Valérie C
15 posts

About author
I love turning simple ingredients into refreshing little moments of joy. From comforting teas to colorful fruit drinks, I share easy recipes that make drinking well feel natural, delicious, and fun. For me, every cup is a chance to slow down and savor something good.
Articles
You may also like
Homemade Sodas

Dunkin Dirty Soda at Home With Coffee Milk, Cola and Sweet Cold Foam

8 Mins read
Homemade Sodas

Dirty Soda Syrups at Home: Coconut, Vanilla and Raspberry From One Pot

7 Mins read
Homemade Sodas

Spiced Simple Syrup With Cinnamon, Clove and Star Anise

9 Mins read

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Recipe Rating